The continualisation of discrete particle models has been a popular tool to
formulate higher-order gradient elasticity models. However, a straightforward
continualisation leads to unstable continuum models. Padé approximations can
be used to stabilise the model, but the resulting formulation depends on
the particular equation that is transformed with the Padé approximation.
In this contribution, we study two different stabilised gradient elasticity
models; one is an irreducible form with displacement degrees of freedom
only, and the other is a reducible form where the primary unknowns are
not only displacements but also the Cauchy stresses — this turns out to
be Eringen’s theory of gradient elasticity. Although they are derived from
the same discrete model, there are significant differences in variationally
consistent boundary conditions and resulting finite element implementations,
with implications for the capability (or otherwise) to suppress crack tip
singularities.