The CPAM board endorses the following principles to guide our stewardship of the journal in the age of AI.
- The role of top mathematics journals is to select and publicize the most important research in mathematics.
- Journals should not discourage authors, editors, and reviewers from using powerful AI tools.
- Journals should publish a broad range of mathematical work.
- Journals should remain flexible with respect to evolving standards of authorship, disclosure, and collaboration.
Journals have often been pressed into other roles, like apportioning credit and prestige or establishing priority or correctness. We believe these secondary roles will become much less important, while the role of top journals as a “virtual common room” for mathematics will continue. Journal editors have always sought to exercise their judgment to promote the most exciting, interesting, and consequential work in their field. This should not change. In the likely event that the pace of mathematical progress increases substantially and the importance of problem solving per se diminishes, journals should not necessarily publish the entirety of all newly produced results but instead strive to publish the work that best reflects the broad virtues of excellent mathematics, in the eyes of expert mathematicians.
Artificial intelligence is likely to play a central role in the future of mathematical research. Top journals should embrace the possibilities opened by new technology.
Mathematical progress consists not only in solving problems, but also in asking good questions, opening up new directions, and building research programs. Journals should embrace these interrelated aspects of mathematical discovery, including by being willing to publish excellent expository, heuristic, conjectural, or experimental work, when appropriate.
Community norms around AI use, AI-enhanced collaboration, and AI authorship are in flux. Journals should be wary of unilaterally imposing standards that fall out of step with changes in mathematical practice.
